[Feature request] Honolulu should be able to send Email notifications
Please add a functionality to Honolulu that enables the Honolulu Server to send Email notifications. There should be two options:
1. a global value to be notified via Email if there are Warnings/Alerts - the should be a option to chose: notify for warnings and alerts and notify only for alerts
2. it would be great to have an button nearby important configurable values "create alert" and then there should be an option to configure a value and chose if the notification should be send when the running value gets greater or smaller than the configured value
The SMTP Server for the Email notification should be configurable.
YOU NGUOI DUNG CUOI VA CAC NOI TREN HE THONG NAY DO APPLE , GOOGLE, HAY MSC ...CHOM BANK HOP TAC
Ja, gute Idee, bitte umsetzen.
Yes, gute Idee. Bitte umsetzen.
Gerade für kleine Lösungen perfekt.
E-Mail is very helpful especially for single system or small companies
Ryan Helmer commented
I really don't understand the disagreement with the idea that WAC could provide alerts (perhaps email isn't the ideal approach for everyone, but it's better than what many have now; up-sell a connection to an Azure service for more/better options? With AI, reporting, performance trends, etc.?):
- Setting up alerts manually in Perfmon? Goodness gracious, wouldn't it be nice to have a tool to set that up, across many machines? (WAC, where you been all my life? :D )
- Wouldn't it be nice to have some canned, these-are-the-alerts-you're-looking-for you could set up immediately, instead of being left on your own trying to sort through the myriad options in Perfmon... kind of how WAC approaches things? "Hey, please just tell me if I'm running out of disk space!"
- SCOM? Ugh. If you're the kind of shop that would run SCOM (and has the resources to configure and tame it from its wild-west defaults), you probably aren't that interested in WAC anyway.
There are tons of tools out there that do this, but most shoot for flexibility at the expense of simplicity, and become yet one more thing to learn, manage, and maintain. One reason people are so jazzed about WAC is that it greatly simplifies management. Why rudimentary alerting should be intentionally left out is baffling.
I see that many ppl see this as a bad idea, but i cannot understand why.
I can understand that in enterprise segment there are many better options, but we in small business sector definitely need this. Especially as an outsourced it deploying single boxes on premise or 2node systems, this could alert admins and no more scripting would be needed. I agree that plugin would be best sollution.
Bad idea for two reasons :
- WAC is not a monitoring tool, it has not been designed for this
- Email alerting is bad in general
Nicki Messerschmidt commented
That would be a nice addon to wac
Tony Salmijarvi commented
Yes please. Make it like Nagios
Should be an extension! Keep it lightweight but where customers do not have full blown SCOM, this would be perfect.
Alistair Ross [MSFT] commented
I disagree completely with this. Email notifications are bad when configured in an Enterprise environment. Performance metrics can alert using Perfmon https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/2424491/how-to-create-performance-counter-alert-and-send-email-when-the-alert But for scale I would use either System Center Operations Manager or Azure Services to monitor and alert on my data
disagree strongly... this is not designed for that task. Keep it lightweight like it is now. E-mail notifications can already be configured elsewhere; It would be handy though to configure those (like scom) messages through honolulu. So configuring scom through Honolulu / wac yes, let Honolulu / wac manage those e-mails / messages: NO.
Richard Hooper commented
I asked about this kind of monitoring/reports in an Ask Me Anything session Microsoft was having. They probably won't be doing this as the tool is only for managing your servers/systems not monitoring it. you can read their answer here https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/Windows-Server-AMA/Email-reports/m-p/117350#M194
Manfred Helber commented
Hi Anthony, yes, I understand how WAC works. So why did I create this Uservoice request? I delivered a lot of Honolulu Demos... The most asked question was: "How can I configure an Email Alert?" - so it seems the Admins like WAC but they expect some notification option there.
Anthony Yates commented
Although its a good idea that would be very useful I don't think you guys understand how this tool works. This is not a service that is constantly polling this data from your servers. It's also not storing historical stats from your servers. The only time it retrieves this information is when you login and connect to a specific server to monitor it.
Unless Microsoft plan to significantly change how this product works I wouldn't expect to see this feature anytime soon.
Reinhard Knoblich commented